Comments on The Legend of Cecilio Guante: No-MAH Garciaparra and HOF: Discuss

Mia Hamm is pretty impressive, but my answer is a ...

2009-07-07T18:37:29.850-04:00

Mia Hamm is pretty impressive, but my answer is a resounding no. As a Yankees fan, I do like Nomar though -- he's part of the reason we dominated in the late 90s. (because he couldn't hit in the clutch)

Not a chance. With or without the steroids....just...

2009-07-07T13:37:08.399-04:00

Not a chance. With or without the steroids....just no.

Mia Hamm.....she's nice....I'd give him a triple on that pull.

agreed, ES. gut is usually the most reliable sourc...

2009-07-07T12:55:33.370-04:00

agreed, ES. gut is usually the most reliable source when it comes to HOF discussion. first response, usually best. funny...i did think about trying to integrate Hamm into conversation...couldn't come up with a stat for that

Off the top of my head, not looking at stats, I sa...

2009-07-07T12:48:21.784-04:00

Off the top of my head, not looking at stats, I say no. But, you factor in landing Mia Hamm....maybe.

Doesn't even have 2000 hits so, no. Although, I'll...

2009-07-07T02:42:38.745-04:00

Doesn't even have 2000 hits so, no. Although, I'll always maintain that Nomar was my favorite amongst his contemporaries: Jeter, Rodriguez, Tejada.

He's had a nice career, but not a chance. If he ha...

2009-07-06T22:35:01.787-04:00

He's had a nice career, but not a chance. If he had not got hurt, maybe he would have had that type of career.